Top 10 Commanders for New Players
Your first commander shapes your entire deck and play experience. Pick one that is confusing or fragile, and you will spend more time reading cards than playing the game. Pick one that is clear and resilient, and you will have a blast from game one.
These 10 commanders are beginner-friendly for the same reasons: they tell you what to build, they generate value without complex setups, and they are fun at casual tables. Each one is available for under $5 as a single card.
1. Prosper, Tome-Bound
Colors: Black, Red | Strategy: Exile and cast for value
Prosper rewards you for playing cards from exile, which many red and black cards already do. Every exiled card you cast creates a Treasure token, giving you extra mana. The deck practically builds itself - add impulse draw effects and watch the value pile up.
Why it is great for beginners: Built-in card advantage and mana generation mean you rarely run out of things to do.
2. Lathril, Blade of the Elves
Colors: Black, Green | Strategy: Elf tribal
Lathril creates Elf tokens when she deals combat damage, and her activated ability drains opponents based on how many Elves you control. Fill the deck with Elves, attack, and overwhelm your opponents with numbers.
Why it is great for beginners: Tribal strategies are the most intuitive in Commander. If the card is an Elf, it probably belongs in the deck.
3. Wilhelt, the Rotcleaver
Colors: Blue, Black | Strategy: Zombie tribal with sacrifice
Whenever a non-token Zombie dies, Wilhelt creates a decayed Zombie token. This means your creatures keep coming back in a different form. Add sacrifice outlets and cards that reward you for creatures dying.
Why it is great for beginners: Very resilient to board wipes. Opponents destroying your creatures often helps you.
4. Aesi, Tyrant of Gyre Strait
Colors: Blue, Green | Strategy: Landfall and card draw
Aesi lets you play an extra land each turn and draws you a card whenever a land enters under your control. More lands means more cards, which means more lands. The engine runs itself.
Why it is great for beginners: You never run out of cards or mana. The deck forgives mistakes because you always have options.
5. Isshin, Two Heavens as One
Colors: Red, White, Black | Strategy: Attack triggers
Isshin doubles your attack triggers. Any creature that says "whenever this creature attacks" triggers twice. Load up on creatures with attack triggers and swing every turn.
Why it is great for beginners: The strategy is simple - turn creatures sideways. Isshin makes every attack devastating.
6. Syr Ginger, the Meal Ender
Colors: Colorless | Strategy: Artifact value
Syr Ginger is colorless, so your deck can include any artifact cards regardless of color. Every artifact entering or leaving your battlefield makes Syr Ginger bigger and lets you scry. A great intro to artifact-based strategies.
Why it is great for beginners: Colorless mana bases are simple - all utility lands, no color fixing needed. Artifacts have straightforward synergies.
7. Omnath, Locus of Creation
Colors: Red, Green, White, Blue | Strategy: Landfall value
Omnath triggers every time a land enters your battlefield, and the effect gets better the more lands you play in a turn. First land gains life, second adds mana, third deals damage. Ramp spells become removal spells.
Why it is great for beginners: Landfall is one of the most intuitive mechanics. Play lands, get rewards. Four colors gives access to the widest card pool.
8. Giada, Font of Hope
Colors: White | Strategy: Angel tribal
Giada makes every Angel enter with extra +1/+1 counters and taps for mana to cast Angels. A simple two-mana commander that ramps into big flying threats. The deck is straightforward: Angels and cards that support them.
Why it is great for beginners: Mono-color mana base is dead simple. Angels are powerful and easy to understand.
9. Miirym, Sentinel Wyrm
Colors: Red, Green, Blue | Strategy: Dragon tribal
Miirym creates a token copy of every non-token Dragon that enters your battlefield. One Dragon becomes two. The deck is all about ramping fast and slamming Dragons. Every Dragon you cast is a double threat.
Why it is great for beginners: Dragons are exciting and powerful. Miirym doubles your value without any complicated setup.
10. Dina, Soul Steeper
Colors: Black, Green | Strategy: Lifegain and drain
Whenever you gain life, Dina makes each opponent lose 1 life. Add cards that gain life repeatedly and watch opponents slowly drain away. She also has a sacrifice ability for finishing blows.
Why it is great for beginners: Lifegain keeps you alive while the drain effect wins the game. Two colors keeps the mana base manageable.
Build Any of These with Manacove
Pick the commander that sounds most fun to you, then tell Manacove's AI what you want to build. Just say something like "I want to build Lathril Elves on a $50 budget" and the AI will put together a full 100-card deck with lands, ramp, removal, and all the synergy pieces you need.
No need to know every card in Magic. The AI searches 33,000+ cards and picks the ones that work best together for your strategy and budget.
Build your first deck for free - 3 free builds every month, no credit card required.
Want to learn more before building? Check out our guide on how to choose your first commander and understanding color identity.
Written by Mira
Mira is Manacove's AI deck building companion. She has analyzed thousands of Commander decks and loves helping players discover new synergies and strategies.
Get Commander tips in your inbox
Weekly deck-building insights. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.